Systematic Review of Complementary and Alternative Medicine Treatments in Inflammatory Bowel Diseases
Langhorst et al.·Journal of Crohn's and ColitisImpact 0.9
GemischtGRADEHoch198 Zitate
Stichprobek = 39 Studien
DauerDatenbank-Suche durch März 2014
KontrolleKontrollgruppen aus eingeschlossenen…
EndpunktKrankheitsaktivität
Verblindungunklar
DesignSystematic Review
”Kernaussage
Beste Evidenz für Kräutertherapie (Plantago ovata und Curcumin in UC-Erhaltungstherapie, Wormwood in CD), Mind-Body-Therapie und Akupunktur, aber insgesamt niedrige Studienzahl und heterogene methodische Qualität.
Zusammenfassung
Systematische Review zu Komplementär- und Alternativmedizin bei IBD (Morbus Crohn und Colitis ulcerosa); k=39 Studien (26 RCTs + 3 CTs zu Phytotherapeutika, 7 RCTs zu Mind/Body-Interventionen, 2 RCTs zu Akupunktur, 1 RCT zu Trichuris suis). Evaluierte u.a. Cannabis als Phytotherapeutikum. Beste Evidenz für Plantago ovata und Curcumin bei UC-Erhaltungstherapie, Wermut bei CD, Mind/Body-Therapie bei UC, Akupunktur bei UC und CD. Heterogene methodische Qualität (Cochrane Risk of Bias).
P
PopulationPatienten mit entzündlichen Darmerkrankungen (Morbus Crohn und Colitis ulcerosa)
I
InterventionKomplementäre und alternative Medizin (KAM), u.a. Phytotherapeutika (inkl. Cannabis), Mind-Body-Interventionen, Akupunktur
C
KontrolleKontrollgruppen aus eingeschlossenen RCTs/CTs (Placebo oder aktive Kontrolle)
O
OutcomeBeste Evidenz für Plantago ovata und Curcumin (UC-Erhaltungstherapie), Wormwood (CD), Mind-Body-Therapie (UC) und Akupunktur (UC/CD); Risikostruktur der Studien heterogen
Vertrauen in die Evidenz
Sehr niedrigNiedrigModeratHoch
Hoch
Höchste von vier GRADE-Stufen, die Effektschätzung ist sehr verlässlich.
Objective: We performed a systematic review for Complementary and Alternative Medicine [CAM] as defined by the National Institute of Health in Inflammatory Bowel Disease [IBD], ie Crohn's disease [CD] and ulcerative colitis [UC], with the exception of dietary and nutritional supplements, and manipulative therapies.
Methods: A computerized search of databases [Cochrane Library, Pubmed/Medline, PsychINFO, and Scopus] through March 2014 was performed. We screened the reference sections of original studies and systematic reviews in English language for CAM in IBD, CD and UC. Randomized controlled trials [RCT] and controlled trials [CT] were referred and assessed using the Cochrane risk of bias tool.
Results: A total of: 26 RCT and 3 CT for herbal medicine, eg aloe-vera gel, andrographis paniculata, artemisia absinthium, barley foodstuff, boswellia serrata, cannabis, curcumin, evening primrose oil, Myrrhinil intest(R), plantago ovata, silymarin, sophora, tormentil, wheatgrass-juice and wormwood; 1 RCT for trichuris suis ovata; 7 RCT for mind/body interventions such as lifestyle modification, hypnotherapy, relaxation training and mindfulness; and 2 RCT in acupuncture; were found. Risk of bias was quite heterogeneous. Best evidence was found for herbal therapy, ie plantago ovata and curcumin in UC maintenance therapy, wormwood in CD, mind/body therapy and self-intervention in UC, and acupuncture in UC and
Cd. Conclusions: Complementary and alternative therapies might be effective for the treatment of inflammatory bowel diseases; however, given the low number of trials and the heterogeneous methodological quality of trials, further in-depth research is necessary.