Opioid-sparing effect of cannabinoids for analgesia: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis of preclinical and clinical studies
Nielsen et al.·NeuropsychopharmacologyImpact 4.4
GemischtGRADEHoch87 Zitate
Stichprobek = 92 Studien
Dauer2016 onwards
KontrolleOpioide allein bzw. Placebo
EndpunktOpioid-Dosisbedarf / Analgesie
Verblindungn.a.
DesignMeta-Analyse
”Kernaussage
Vorklinische und Beobachtungsstudien zeigen potenzielle opioid-sparende Effekte von Cannabinoiden, während höherwertige RCTs keine Evidenz für opioid-sparende Effekte nachweisen.
Zusammenfassung
Umfassende SR+MA zu Opioid-sparenden Effekten von Cannabinoiden (k=92 Studien inkl. 15 laufender Trials). Präklinisch: ED50 von Morphin+THC 3.5-fach niedriger als Morphin allein (95% CI 2.04-6.03). Klinisch-akut: 3 RCTs fanden keine Opioid-Einsparung bei Akutschmerz. Krebsschmerz: k=4 RCTs, keine Reduktion der Opioid-Dosis (MD -3.8 mg, 95% CI -10.97 bis 3.37) oder Schmerz-Scores (MD 1.84, 95% CI -2.05 bis 5.72); mehr Nebenwirkungen vs. Placebo (RR 1.13, 95% CI 1.03-1.24). Chronischer Nicht-Krebsschmerz: 3 RCTs ohne Dronabinol-Effekt. Beobachtungsstudien: 39% berichteten Opioid-Stopp (95% CI 0.15-0.64), 85% Reduktion (95% CI 0.64-0.99). Präklinisch/beobachtend potenzial-zeigend, RCT-Evidenz widersprüchlich.
P
PopulationPräklinische Modelle sowie Patienten mit akutem Schmerz, Krebsschmerz und chronischem Nicht-Tumorschmerz – gepoolte Stichprobe variabel über Studien
I
InterventionCannabinoide (u.a. THC, Dronabinol) als Co-Applikation zu Opioiden
C
KontrolleOpioide allein bzw. Placebo
O
OutcomePräklinisch: ED50 Morphin 3,5-fach niedriger mit THC (95% CI 2,04–6,03); RCTs Krebsschmerz: kein Opioid-sparender Effekt (MD –3,8 mg, 95% CI –10,97 bis 3,37); Beobachtungsstudien: 39% Opioid-Stopp, 85% Opioid-Reduktion
Vertrauen in die Evidenz
Sehr niedrigNiedrigModeratHoch
Hoch
Höchste von vier GRADE-Stufen, die Effektschätzung ist sehr verlässlich.
Cannabinoid co-administration may enable reduced opioid doses for analgesia. This updated systematic review on the opioid-sparing effects of cannabinoids considered preclinical and clinical studies where the outcome was analgesia or opioid dose requirements. We searched Scopus, Cochrane Central Registry of Controlled Trials, Medline, and Embase (2016 onwards). Ninety-two studies met the search criteria including 15 ongoing trials. Meta-analysis of seven preclinical studies found the median effective dose (ED(50)) of morphine administered with delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol was 3.5 times lower (95% CI 2.04, 6.03) than the ED(50) of morphine alone. Six preclinical studies found no evidence of increased opioid abuse liability with cannabinoid administration. Of five healthy-volunteer experimental pain studies, two found increased pain, two found decreased pain and one found reduced pain bothersomeness with cannabinoid administration; three demonstrated that cannabinoid co-administration may increase opioid abuse liability. Three randomized controlled trials (RCTs) found no evidence of opioid-sparing effects of cannabinoids in acute pain. Meta-analysis of four RCTs in patients with cancer pain found no effect of cannabinoid administration on opioid dose (mean difference -3.8 mg, 95% CI -10.97, 3.37) or percentage change in pain scores (mean difference 1.84, 95% CI -2.05, 5.72); five studies found more adverse events with cannabinoids compared with placebo (risk ratio 1.13, 95% CI 1.03, 1.24). Of five controlled chronic non-cancer pain trials; one low-quality study with no control arm, and one single-dose study reported reduced pain scores with cannabinoids. Three RCTs found no treatment effect of dronabinol. Meta-analyses of observational studies found 39% reported opioid cessation (95% CI 0.15, 0.64, I(2) 95.5%, eight studies), and 85% reported reduction (95% CI 0.64, 0.99, I(2) 92.8%, seven studies). In summary, preclinical and observational studies demonstrate the potential opioid-sparing effects of cannabinoids in the context of analgesia, in contrast to higher-quality RCTs that did not provide evidence of opioid-sparing effects.