Meta-analysis of neurocognition in young psychosis patients with current cannabis use
Bogaty et al.·Journal of Psychiatric ResearchImpact 3.0
SchadenGRADEHoch41 Zitate
Stichprobek = 14 Studien
Dauerunklar
KontrolleKein Cannabiskonsum
EndpunktNeurokognitive Testleistung
Verblindungunklar
DesignMeta-Analyse
”Kernaussage
Aktuelle Cannabisnutzer (CANN+) zeigen schlechtere Leistungen in mehreren kognitiven Bereichen (premorbide IQ, aktuelle IQ, verbales Lernen, verbales Arbeitsgedächtnis, motorische Inhibition) im Vergleich zu Nie-Nutzern (CANN-), mit Verschlechterung bei älteren Patienten.
Zusammenfassung
Meta-Analyse über k=14 Studien zu Neurokognition bei jungen Psychose-Patienten (mittleres Alter 15–45 Jahre) mit aktuellem Cannabis-Konsum (CANN+) vs. Never-User (CANN-). CANN+ zeigten schlechtere Performance in mehreren Domänen: prämorbider IQ, aktueller IQ, verbales Lernen, verbales Arbeitsgedächtnis, motorische Inhibition. Höheres Alter prädizierte schlechtere Verarbeitungsgeschwindigkeit, Daueraufmerksamkeit, verbales Gedächtnis. CANN+ übertrafen CANN- nur in Conceptual Set-Shifting. Random-Effects-Modellierung, Moderator-Analysen.
P
PopulationJunge Patienten mit psychotischen Störungen (mittleres Alter 15–45 Jahre), Cannabis-Nutzer (CANN+) vs. Nie-Nutzer (CANN-)
I
InterventionAktueller Cannabiskonsum bei Psychosepatienten
C
KontrolleKein Cannabiskonsum (CANN-)
O
OutcomeCANN+ zeigte schlechtere Leistungen in prämorbider IQ, aktuellem IQ, verbalem Lernen, verbalem Arbeitsgedächtnis und motorischer Inhibition; bessere Leistung in konzeptuellem Set-Shifting; Altersmoderation variierte je nach kognitiver Domäne
Vertrauen in die Evidenz
Sehr niedrigNiedrigModeratHoch
Hoch
Höchste von vier GRADE-Stufen, die Effektschätzung ist sehr verlässlich.
Objective: Adult psychosis patients (i.e. over the age of 25 years) who are also lifetime cannabis users (CANN+/-) appear to exhibit superior cognition compared to never-using patients (CANN-). The objective of this meta-analysis was to evaluate the cognitive differences between CANN- and patients who currently use cannabis (CANN+) (i.e. during the CANN+/- patients' cannabis-using stage). Specifically, focusing on young patients under the age of 25 years, the typical stage of both psychosis- and cannabis-onset.
Method: Of the 308 studies identified through database searches and secondary referencing, 14 compared neurocognition of CANN+ and CANN- in young people with psychotic disorders (mean age between 15 and 45 years). Effect sizes were extracted using neurocognitive test performance between CANN+ and CANN- and random effects modelling was conducted on pooled ES and moderator analyses.
Results: CANN+ performed worse on several cognitive domains (i.e. premorbid IQ, current IQ, verbal learning, verbal working memory, motor inhibition) compared to CANN-. The association between age and performance in CANN+ cognition was varied, with older age predictive of worse performance in processing speed, sustained attention, verbal memory, and better performance in verbal learning and very fluency. Of note, CANN+ outperformed CANN- in tests of conceptual set-shifting.
Conclusion: These results are consistent with previous findings indicating that CANN+ demonstrate poorer neurocognition than CANN-; and that this is exacerbated with increasing age. Our findings demonstrate significant cognitive differences between patients with CANN+ versus CANN- even at early-onset psychosis, which could suggest a different underlying mechanism towards psychosis for cannabis users.